Skip to main content
Decisions Blog Library

Why Smart People Make Bad Financial Decisions

Photo of author, Will Carter, JD.
Will Carter, JD
Senior Advisor

The most consistent way that McKinley Carter helps its clients is simply by helping them avoid making mistakes with their money.

Some mistakes are caused by ignorance. Others by predictable, but sloppy, thinking.

Mistakes caused by ignorance are relatively easy for our advisors to help people avoid. Our expertise in financial matters and our ability to teach clients what they can do to take better care of their financial situation generally is enough.

But many mistakes are not caused by lack of education or intelligence. Rather, they are caused by what the article below calls “dysrationalia” – the tendency of people of all intelligence levels, especially the smartest, to make foolish decisions due to mental shortcuts and/or non-rigorous thinking about probability.

This is harder to manage, precisely because smart people don’t tend to think of themselves as capable of making what in hindsight might seem like foolish decisions. But we all do to some extent. One of the first steps to avoiding making such decisions is having the humility to recognize that natural tendency.

The article below contains several test questions that can help you assess the extent to which you have learned to manage the tendency to apply “dysrational” thinking. If you’re like me, you will find it a humbling, but informative, experience.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/rational-and-irrational-thought-the-thinking-that-iq-tests-miss/

Related Insights
Family 3347049 1920

Financial Goal-Setting Starts with 'the End in Mind'

Setting financial goals is critical to smart family finance. Sounds easy, right? Not quite. For many of us, it's difficult to know where to begin when it comes to our personal finances. What kind of goals should you set and how can you be sure you're on the right track to achieving them? Learn how "beginning with the end in mind" can help you in your financial goal-setting.

Read More
Drums 2089829 1920

The Beat Goes On: Vaccine Optimism Paved Way for 2020 Record Highs, Sets Stage for 2021

What a year we experienced in 2020! The most tumultuous year in recent memory ended on a high note for markets as the fourth quarter brought greater political and medical clarity — one that resulted in substantial market gains over the past three months, which helped to make 2020 a surprisingly strong year for market returns. What can we expect in 2021?

Read More
Patch 3 Iron Grip Retirement edited

Do You Have an ‘Iron Grip’ on Successful Retirement Planning?

If you're wondering if you will be able to live comfortably in retirement, you must first determine what "comfortable" means to you and the associated level of spending. No matter what the level, comfort increases with confidence in knowing pre- and post-retirement spending needs.

Read More
Play